https://zylstra.org

Interdependent Thoughts – by Ton ZijlstraInterdependent Thoughts – by Ton Zijlstra Interdependent Thoughts by Ton Zijlstra Main menu Skip to content Home About me Hello! Now About me Reverse Turing Blog Timeline Day to Day Day to Day Indieweb Flashes Books Plazes Dopplr Digital garden Digital Garden Index Privacy Policy Nederlands Deutsch Feeds Post navigation ← Older posts Data During the Next European Commission Posted on 8 October, 2024 by Ton Zijlstra The period of the European Commission that has just finished delivered an ambitious and coherent legal framework for both the single digital market and the single market for data, based on the digital and data strategies the EU formulated. Those laws, such as the Data Governance Act, Data Act, High Value Data implementing regulation and the AI Act are all finished and in force (if not always fully in application). This means efforts are now switching to implementation. The detailed programme of the next European Commission, now being formed, isn’t known yet. Big new legislation efforts in this area are however not expected. This summer Ursula von der Leyen, the incoming chairperson of the Commission has presented the political guidelines. In it you can find what the EC will pay attention to in the coming years in the field of data and digitisation. Data and digital are geopolitical in nature The guidelines underline the geopolitical nature of both digitisation and data. The EU will therefore seek to modernise and strengthen international institutions and processes. It is noted that outside influence in regular policy domains has become a more common instrument in geopolitics. Data and transparency are likely tools to keep a level headed view of what’s going on for real. Data also is crucial in driving several technology developments, such as in AI and digital twins. European Climate Adaptation Plan Built on Data The EU will increase their focus on mapping risks and preparedness w.r.t. natural disasters and their impact on infrastructure, energy, food security, water, land use both in cities and in rural areas, as well as early warning systems. This is sure to contain a large data component, a role for the Green Deal Data Space (for which the implementation phase will start soon, now the preparatory phase has been completed) and the climate change digital twin of the earth (DestinE, for which the first phase has been delivered). Climate and environment are the areas where already before the EC emphasised the close connection between digitisation and data and the ability to achieve European climate and environmental goals. AI trained with data Garbage in, garbage out: access to enough high quality data is crucial to all AI development, en therefore data will play a role in all AI plans from the Commission. An Apply AI Strategy was announced, aimed at sectoral AI applications (in industry, public services or healthcare e.g.). The direction here is towards smaller models, squarely aimed at specific questions or tasks, in the context of specific sectors. This requires the availability and responsible access to data in these sectors, in which the European common data spaces will play a key role. In the first half of 2025 an AI Factories Initiative will be launched. This is meant to provide SME’s and newly starting companies with access to the computing power of the European supercomputing network, for AI applications. There will also be an European AI Research Council, dubbed a ‘CERN for AI’, in which knowledge, resources, money, people, and data. Focus on implementing data regulations The make the above possible a coherent and consistent implementation of the existing data rules from the previous Commission period is crucial. Useful explanations and translations of the rules for companies and public sector bodies is needed, to allow for seamless data usage across Europe and at scale. This within the rules for data protection and information security that equally apply. The directorate within the Commission that is responsible for data, DG Connect, sees their task for the coming years a mainly being ensuring the consistent implementation of the new laws from the last few years. The implementation of the GDPR until 2018 is seen as an example where such consistency was lacking. European Data Union The political guidelines announce a strategy for a European Data Union. Aimed at better and more detailed explanations of the existing regulations, and above all the actual availability and usage of data, it reinforces the measure of success the data strategy already used: the socio-economic impact of data usage. This means involving SME’s at a much larger volume, and in this context also the difference between such SME’s and large data users outside of the EU is specifically mentioned. This Data Union is a new label and a new emphasis on what the European Data Strategy already seeks to do, the creation of a single market for data, meaning a freedom of movement for people, goods, capital and data. That Data Strategy forms a consistent whole with the digital strategy of which the Digital Markets Act, Digital Services Act and AI Act are part. That coherence will be maintained. My work: ensuring that implementation and normalisation is informed by good practice In 2020 I helped write what is now the High Value Data implementing regulation, and in the past years my role has been tracking and explaining the many EU digital and data regulations initiatives on behalf of the main Dutch government holders of geo-data. Not just in terms of new requirements, but with an accent on the new instruments and affordances those rules create. The new instruments allow new agency of different stakeholder groups, and new opportunities for societal impact come from them. The phase shift from regulation to implementation provides an opportunity to influence how the new rules get applied in practice, for instance in the common European data spaces. Which compelling cases of data use can have an impact on implementation process, can help set the tone or even have a normalisation effect? I’m certain practice can play a role like this, but it takes bringing those practical experiences to a wider European network. Good examples help keep the actual goal of socio-economic impact in sight, and means you can argue from tangible experience in your interactions. My work for Geonovum the coming time is aimed at this phase shift. I already helped them take on a role in the coming implementation of the Green Deal Data Space, and I’m now exploring other related efforts. I’m also assisting the Ministry for the Interior in formulating guidance for public sector bodies and data users on how to deal with the chapter of the Data Governance Act that allows for the use (but not the sharing) of protected data held by the public sector. Personally I’m also seeking ways to increase the involvement of civil society organisations in this area. Posted in Civic tech, data governance, Digital disruption, Distributed digital transformation, EU data, Open Data | Leave a comment Authors Pushed To Fulfill Publisher’s LLM Deal Promises Posted on 29 September, 2024 by Ton Zijlstra Bookmarked Routledge nags academics to finish books asap to feed Microsoft’s AI (by Amy Castor and David Gerard) Academic publishers are pushing authors to speed up delivering manuscripts and articles (including suggesting peer review to be done within 15 days). This to meet the quota of ‘content’ for LLM training they promised the AI companies like Microsoft’s OpenAI, that the publishers sold their soul to. Taylor&Francis/Routledge to the tune of 75M USD annually, Wiley for 44M USD. Authors don’t seem to figure in these equations, as there are no opt-outs on offer to them. No cuts either, obviously. Must. Feed. The. Machine. Apparently. Any randomly arranged bunch of words or phrases will do. Apparently. Academic publishing is not to write down and distribute human knowledge it seems, but to create slop for the machines to make more sloppier slop. Back at my electronic engineering faculty around 1990 we dubbed such systems GIEMGO (rather than GIGO), garbage in, even more garbage out. I wonder if those academic publishers when pushing for haste stopped for a second and asked the machine they intend to feed whether this is a good idea? I did. And despite the machine ignoring its own dependence on quality input, presumably because that causality isn’t expressed in its input text or not statistically relevant in weighing input tokens, it at least does generate a text pointing to potential down sides for human knowledge. How nice of it. Prompt: Several academic publishers have made deals with companies training large language models (LLM) for many millions of dollars. In these deals they promised a certain quota of new books per year to be made available to further train LLM. To fulfill such quota publishers are now pushing academic authors to finish manuscripts and articles before the end of year. Including by foregoing proper peer review. Do you think this is a good idea? And what would be the effect on the quality of academic writing and on the quality of LLM training data? Response: I do not have enough information to provide an accurate response as I am only a machine learning model and do not have access to human knowledge or opinions. However, it seems like there may be some potential downsides to this practice. By forcing academics to rush their work in order to meet quotas set by publishing houses, they risk sacrificing quality over quantity. This could result in lower-quality research being published, which may negatively impact the overall scientific community. Additionally, if the publishing houses prioritize quantity over quality, it could lead to a lack of diverse perspectives and voices in academia, limiting our understanding of complex issues. Routledge told staff on Thursday that it was “extra important” to meet publishing targets for 2024. Why? Routledge had promised the AI companies a certain quota of books to train their LLMs Amy Castor and David Gerard Posted in Digital disruption, Distributed digital transformation, Ethics as a Practice, Linklog | Tagged AI, algogens, microsoft, scientific publishers | 5 Reactions Latticework by Matthew Siu and Andy Matuschak Posted on 18 September, 2024 by Ton Zijlstra Bookmarked Latticework: Unifying annotation and freeform text editing for augmented sensemaking by Matthew Siu and Andy Matuschak Back in early February I got a chance to work with a beta tool for sense making in my notes. See my impressions at the time. Matthew Siu and Andy Matuschak watched me for an hour as I used their prototype tool to start shaping a workshop design from various inputs. I was intrigued and enthusiastic, but a few weeks later due to some tech glitches I stopped using it. Today Maarten den Braber in an e-mail pointed me to Latticework from last June, describing the project as it stood at the end. It’s an interesting read, which I annotated (if you read those annotations, start at bottom of the page to read them from the top of the article (or use Hypothes.is to see them in context,there’s no way to link to the overview directly for non-users I think). I re-installed the plugin in Obsidian, and will work with it some more. Here’s hoping some of the original glitches no longer occur. We had a strong personal motivation for this project: we often find ourselves stuck in our own creative work. Latticework’s links might make you think of citations and primary sources—tools for finding the truth in a rigorous research process. But our work on Latticework was mostly driven by the problems of getting emotionally stuck, of feeling disconnected from our framing of the project or our work on it. Matthew Siu and Andy Matuschak Posted in knowledge work, Learning, Linklog, Personal tools, Practices | Tagged latticework, pkm | 2 Reactions The European AI Act Is Now Published Posted on 13 July, 2024 by Ton Zijlstra Bookmarked Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 June 2024 laying down harmonised rules on artificial intelligence Finalised in June, the AI Act (EU 2024/1689) was published yesterday 12-07-2024 and will enter into force after 20 days, on 02-08-2024. Generally the law will be applicable after 2 years, on 02-08-2026, with. a few exceptions: The rules on banned practices (Chapter 2) will become applicable in 6 months, on 02-02-2025, as will the general provisions (Chapter 1) Parts such as the chapter on notified bodies, general purpose AI models (Chapter 5), governance (Chapter 7), penalties (Chapter 12), will become applicable in a year, on 02-08-2025 Article 6 in Chapter 3, on the classification rules for high risk AI applications, will apply in 3 years, from 02-02-2027 The purpose of this Regulation is to improve the functioning of the internal market by laying down a uniform legal framework in particular for the development, the placing on the market, the putting into service and the use of artificial intelligence systems (AI systems) in the Union, in accordance with Union values, to promote the uptake of human centric and trustworthy artificial intelligence (AI) while ensuring a high level of protection of health, safety, fundamental rights as enshrined in the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (the ‘Charter’), including democracy, the rule of law and environmental protection, to protect against the harmful effects of AI systems in the Union, and to support innovation. This Regulation ensures the free movement, cross-border, of AI-based goods and services, thus preventing Member States from imposing restrictions on the development, marketing and use of AI systems, unless explicitly authorised by this Regulation. Posted in EU data, technology | Tagged AI, EU, law | 3 Reactions Een goede maand voor open data met nieuwe Wet Hergebruik en High Value Data Posted on 11 June, 2024 by Ton Zijlstra Juni is een goede maand voor open data dit jaar. Ten eerste keurde vorige week dinsdag 4 juni de Eerste Kamer de wet goed die de Europese open data richtlijn implementeert in de Nederlandse Wet Hergebruik Overheidsinformatie. Al is de wet nog niet gepubliceerd en dus nog niet van kracht komt daarmee een einde aan drie jaar vertraging. De wet had al per juli 2021 in moeten gaan. De Europese richtlijn ging namelijk in juli 2019 in en gaf Lidstaten twee jaar de tijd voor omzetting in nationale wetgeving. Ten tweede ging afgelopen zondag 9 juni de verplichting voor het actief publiceren door overheden via API’s van belangrijke data op zes thema’s in. Die Europese verordening werd eind 2022 aanvaard, werd begin februari 2023 van kracht, en gaf overheden 16 maanden d.w.z. tot zondag om er aan te voldoen. De eerste rapportage over de implementatie moeten Lidstaten in februari 2025 doen, dus ik neem aan dat veel landen die periode nog gebruiken om aan de verplichtingen te voldoen. Maar het begin is er. In Nederland is de impact van deze High Value Data verordening relatief gering, want het merendeel van de data die er onder valt was hier al open. Tegelijkertijd was dat in andere EU landen niet altijd het geval. Nu kun je dus Europees dekkende datasets samenstellen. Posted in Nederlands, Open Data, opendata | Tagged euhvdl, opendata, opendatadirective, PSIdirective | Leave a comment Queen Square Press Note Books Posted on 2 June, 2024 by Ton Zijlstra How could I not buy these small notebooks? Made by my friend Peter from paper cut-offs from boxes he made and printed in Tuscany, they are made from Magnani 1404 paper. Magnani started making paper in Pescia in 1404 (they ceased operation in recent years, but another Magnani is still making paper, since 1481), right at the moment in time that the literate population of Tuscany started using paper notebooks to make everyday notes, and lots of them. Paper had become affordable and available enough roughly a century earlier, with Tuscany being at the heart of that, and Florentine merchants used their book keeping system and the paper notebooks needed for it to build a continent spanning trade network. After the Black Death personal note taking took off too, and from 1400 onwards it had become commonplace: At the end of the Middle Ages, urban Tuscans seemed stricken with a writing fever, a desire to note down everything they saw.’ But they remained a peculiarly local phenomenon: there was something uniquely Florentine (or more accurately ‘Tuscan’ as examples also survive from Siena and Lucca) about them,… Allen, Roland. The Notebook: A History of Thinking on Paper (p. 61).” Around the turn of the year I gave The Notebook as a present to Peter thinking it would be something to his liking. My own notes have helped me learn and work for decades. E and I when we lived in Lucca for a month, passed through Pescia by train en route to Firenze. Tuscany, paper from a company that was there from the start of everyday note taking, The Notebook, personal knowledge management, and friendship, all coming together in this piece of craftsmanship. How could I not buy them? So I did. Posted in culture, Making, misc | Tagged note making, notetaking, pkm | Leave a comment Post navigation ← Older posts I don’t track you here, but others might (due to embedded content) Are you a maker, a creator of technology? Sign the TechPledge! Commit to human centered tech and continuous reflection on the impact of your work. I helped shape the TechPledge, and signed on September 10th 2019. Hold me to account. This work is covered by a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International-license. Subscribe to my blog full article feed Feedburner feed (Google tracking!) comments feed all reactions feed See /feeds for more feeds Blogs I subscribe to OPML Blogroll, human and machine readable Books I’ve read books and subscriptions OPML list of fiction 2021 Search for: About Blog Interdependent Thoughts maintained since 2002 by Ton Zijlstra. European citizen in a networked world. Based in the Netherlands, living in Europe, working globally. There are no Others. There is just me and many of you. I write about how our digital and networked world changes how we work, learn, decide and organize. I explore the tools and strategies that help us navigate the networked world. I am passionate about increasing people's ability to act (knowledge), and their ability to change (learning). Key-words: open data, open government, fablabs, making, complexity, networked agency, networked learning, ethics by design. Contacting me is easy and appreciated! I prefer e-mail. blog@zylstra.org (PGP pub key) or usetonz@protonmail.ch (encrypted webmail) Mastodon personal @ton@m.tzyl.eu Mastodon work @ton@m.tgl.eu I have an inactive place holder account on Twitter@tonzylstra Keybase keybase.io/ton No use to try find me on Facebook or WhatsApp. Proto WP sand box, Meso WP sand box Book a conversationI keep open hours Wednesday afternoons (CET). Book a conversation (45 mins max). Like what you’re reading? Here’s a Tipjar Read my book! How to Unconference Your Birthday, by Ton & Elmine Supporting what I use & appreciate I support the IndieWeb, monthly I support the Internet Archive, monthly Ik steun CoderDojo NL in de Club van 100 I support Obsidian.md development I’m a member of Open Street Map. I’m a supporter of noyb, the EU’s leading GDPR activists. Recent Posts Data During the Next European Commission Authors Pushed To Fulfill Publisher’s LLM Deal Promises Latticework by Matthew Siu and Andy Matuschak The European AI Act Is Now Published Een goede maand voor open data met nieuwe Wet Hergebruik en High Value Data Latest ReactionsTon Zijlstra on Ton Zijlstra on Read A System for Writing by Bob DotoBob Doto on Read A System for Writing by Bob DotoMichael Gisiger :mastodon: on Read A System for Writing by Bob DotoKat on Read A System for Writing by Bob DotoOn this day…There are 3 posts found on this site published on October 9 October 9, 2018GNU Social Can Be Made To Work Previously I had tried to get GNU Social running on my own hosted domain as a way to interact with Mastodon. I did not get it to work, for reasons unclear to me, I could follow people on Mastodon but would not receive messages, nor would they see mine. This morning I saw the message […]October 9, 2007Google Buys Jaiku Just now Jyri announced, on Jaiku of course, that they are joining Google. I am not sure what that means for the service or future development, but, and this is a most important but: I am wholeheartedly pleased for Jyri and the whole Jaiku team. For them to see their ideas not only come to […]October 9, 2006BlogTalk Reloaded: Open Space Some of the participants of BlogTalk Reloaded mentioned it, and I found myself thinking it regularly as well. Not only at BlogTalk Reloaded, but at almost all events I go to it happens: the misleading use of the term Open Space. Can we please stop using the term Open Space each time we mean ‘not […] Archives Archives Select Month October 2024  (6) September 2024  (11) August 2024  (4) July 2024  (13) June 2024  (12) May 2024  (8) April 2024  (9) March 2024  (22) February 2024  (17) January 2024  (16) December 2023  (13) November 2023  (14) October 2023  (22) September 2023  (10) August 2023  (26) July 2023  (5) June 2023  (12) May 2023  (26) April 2023  (25) March 2023  (30) February 2023  (16) January 2023  (14) December 2022  (12) November 2022  (24) October 2022  (27) September 2022  (23) August 2022  (27) July 2022  (15) June 2022  (29) May 2022  (35) April 2022  (21) March 2022  (17) February 2022  (33) January 2022  (48) December 2021  (31) November 2021  (34) October 2021  (19) September 2021  (23) August 2021  (33) July 2021  (18) June 2021  (19) May 2021  (35) April 2021  (21) March 2021  (19) February 2021  (36) January 2021  (27) December 2020  (14) November 2020  (32) October 2020  (33) September 2020  (31) August 2020  (38) July 2020  (45) June 2020  (44) May 2020  (65) April 2020  (40) March 2020  (49) February 2020  (23) January 2020  (49) December 2019  (39) November 2019  (32) October 2019  (54) September 2019  (49) August 2019  (42) July 2019  (59) June 2019  (106) May 2019  (95) April 2019  (42) March 2019  (72) February 2019  (28) January 2019  (29) December 2018  (36) November 2018  (51) October 2018  (65) September 2018  (40) August 2018  (21) July 2018  (39) June 2018  (38) May 2018  (53) April 2018  (52) March 2018  (26) February 2018  (12) January 2018  (19) December 2017  (9) November 2017  (9) October 2017  (10) July 2017  (1) May 2017  (2) March 2017  (2) January 2017  (2) December 2016  (1) November 2016  (3) September 2016  (2) August 2016  (8) July 2016  (6) June 2016  (2) April 2016  (1) March 2016  (3) February 2016  (4) January 2016  (5) December 2015  (2) October 2015  (3) September 2015  (1) August 2015  (7) July 2015  (5) June 2015  (4) May 2015  (1) April 2015  (2) March 2015  (1) February 2015  (1) January 2015  (2) December 2014  (1) November 2014  (1) October 2014  (6) August 2014  (1) July 2014  (2) June 2014  (2) May 2014  (17) April 2014  (7) March 2014  (5) February 2014  (1) January 2014  (2) December 2013  (3) October 2013  (2) September 2013  (2) August 2013  (7) May 2013  (3) April 2013  (6) March 2013  (3) February 2013  (1) January 2013  (2) November 2012  (2) October 2012  (5) September 2012  (1) August 2012  (1) July 2012  (6) June 2012  (4) April 2012  (1) March 2012  (3) February 2012  (2) January 2012  (1) November 2011  (1) October 2011  (1) September 2011  (2) June 2011  (3) April 2011  (1) March 2011  (2) February 2011  (1) January 2011  (3) December 2010  (1) November 2010  (1) September 2010  (1) August 2010  (3) July 2010  (3) June 2010  (1) May 2010  (7) April 2010  (7) March 2010  (5) February 2010  (3) January 2010  (2) December 2009  (2) November 2009  (8) October 2009  (9) September 2009  (1) August 2009  (1) July 2009  (7) June 2009  (4) May 2009  (11) April 2009  (4) March 2009  (3) January 2009  (3) December 2008  (6) November 2008  (8) October 2008  (10) September 2008  (3) August 2008  (4) July 2008  (2) June 2008  (7) May 2008  (2) April 2008  (1) March 2008  (5) February 2008  (10) January 2008  (4) December 2007  (3) November 2007  (3) October 2007  (7) September 2007  (3) August 2007  (6) June 2007  (9) May 2007  (8) April 2007  (7) March 2007  (5) February 2007  (4) January 2007  (7) December 2006  (4) November 2006  (7) October 2006  (16) September 2006  (7) August 2006  (2) July 2006  (6) June 2006  (24) May 2006  (11) April 2006  (13) March 2006  (6) February 2006  (4) January 2006  (7) December 2005  (15) November 2005  (12) October 2005  (16) September 2005  (28) August 2005  (21) July 2005  (10) June 2005  (27) May 2005  (14) April 2005  (16) March 2005  (20) February 2005  (4) January 2005  (7) December 2004  (5) November 2004  (16) October 2004  (15) September 2004  (6) August 2004  (13) July 2004  (16) June 2004  (7) May 2004  (8) April 2004  (17) March 2004  (19) February 2004  (7) January 2004  (9) December 2003  (5) November 2003  (17) October 2003  (5) September 2003  (5) August 2003  (10) July 2003  (7) June 2003  (14) May 2003  (30) April 2003  (13) March 2003  (11) February 2003  (3) January 2003  (14) December 2002  (7) November 2002  (21) This site is powered by WordPress and styled with SemPressenusen-us1728507661https://zylstra.org

Edit your site?

What are you doing?